i
Which “or” Do You Mean? daniel-hromada ()


Which “or” Do You Mean?

In everyday speech “or” is ambiguous. Logic must not be.

sentencereading
“Soup or salad?” (the menu)XOR — not both (unless you pay extra)
“Smoke or heat sets off the alarm.”OR — and certainly if both
“Are you leaving today or tomorrow?”XOR — you cannot leave twice
“Bring a note from your doctor or your parents.”OR — two notes are no problem
“Milk or sugar in your coffee?”unclear! Both, surely?

Latin had two words for it: vel (inclusive: “one or the other or both”) and aut (exclusive: aut Caesar aut nihil). English has just one — and relies on you to guess.