i
α-chimps, narcissism and psychological projection daniel-hromada ()


α-chimps, narcissism and psychological projection

Under every uniform, a primate counting its rank.

Four ingredients: belonging, rank, a grandiose leader, and projection of what we cannot bear in ourselves.

Humans are social 🐒

Belonging is a need. Fascism sells it.

Baumeister & Leary (1995): the need to belong is a fundamental human motivation.

Eisenberger et al. (2003): social exclusion activates brain regions also involved in physical pain.

Fascism offers belonging — paid for with someone else’s exclusion.

Alpha-male

Chimpanzee%2C%20Kibale%2C%20Uganda.%20Rod%20Waddington%2C%20Wikimedia%20Commons%2C%20CC%20BY-SA%202.0

Chimpanzee, Kibale, Uganda. Rod Waddington, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Rank is the oldest story the herd knows.

Frans de Waal, Chimpanzee Politics (1982): a chimpanzee alpha rules through coalitions, favours and peacekeeping — not by brute force alone.

The popular “alpha wolf” comes from captive, unrelated wolves; in the wild a pack is mostly a family (L. D. Mech).

“Alpha” is partly a story we tell. Fascism offers the human edition: a dominance hierarchy with a flag.

Narcistic Personality Disorder

Caravaggio%2C%20Narcissus%20(c.%201597).%20Wikimedia%20Commons%2C%20public%20domain

Caravaggio, Narcissus (c. 1597). Wikimedia Commons, public domain

The leader’s grandiosity needs a crowd to be real.

DSM-5 (APA, 2013): “a pervasive pattern of grandiosity (in fantasy or behavior), need for admiration, and lack of empathy” — five or more of nine criteria.

grandiosity · fantasies of unlimited success · “special” · craves admiration · entitlement · exploits others · no empathy · envy · arrogance (paraphrased)

ICD-11 (WHO) has no separate NPD category. A diagnosis needs a clinician, not a newspaper (the “Goldwater rule”).

What we can study in groups: collective narcissism (Golec de Zavala et al., 2009).

Psychological projection

Hermann%20Rorschach%2C%20inkblot%20no.%208.%20Wikimedia%20Commons%2C%20public%20domain

Hermann Rorschach, inkblot no. 8. Wikimedia Commons, public domain

What I cannot bear in myself, I find in you.

Projection (Freud; Anna Freud, 1936): a defence mechanism — attributing one’s own unacceptable impulses or traits to others.

Collectively: the nation is pure; the impurity is theirs. The Enemy Within is a mirror.

Hence: “Ukrainian fascists” (see Misuse).