👂 🎴 🕸️
<
p
>
Session
0
·
Memetics
begins
at
home
.
p
><
p
>
Before
Internet
memes
''
before
ideology
''
before
theory
:
gestures
''
tunes
''
habits
''
rituals
''
phrases
''
drawings
''
interfaces
and
everyday
acts
of
copying
.
p
>
<
p
style
='
font
-
size
:
1
.
8em
'><
strong
>“
A
meme
is
whatever
is
copied
from
person
to
person
.”
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>—
Susan
Blackmore
''
working
definition
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
For
today
''
let
us
start
with
this
deliberately
simple
definition
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Copying
does
not
necessarily
mean
making
an
exact
duplicate
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
You
hear
a
joke
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
You
remember
the
structure
''
forget
several
words
''
change
a
character
...
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>...
and
tell
it
to
somebody
else
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Something
survived
the
transformation
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
style
='
font
-
size
:
1
.
35em
'><
strong
>
external
expression
→
perception
→
internal
reconstruction
→
expression
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
meme
can
appear
outside
us
:
as
sound
''
gesture
''
image
''
text
''
object
''
ritual
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
It
can
be
reconstructed
inside
us
:
as
memory
''
rule
''
association
''
expectation
''
intention
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Then
it
can
become
external
again
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
What
exactly
is
being
copied
?
strong
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Memetics
is
a
theory
among
other
theories
.
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Human
culture
can
also
be
studied
through
psychology
''
anthropology
''
sociology
''
cultural
evolution
''
semiotics
''
media
theory
''
neuroscience
and
many
other
perspectives
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Memetics
highlights
replication
''
variation
and
selection
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
It
does
not
explain
the
whole
human
being
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
And
although
it
may
begin
to
look
as
if
<
em
>
everything
em
>
is
a
meme
...
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>...
it
is
not
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
virus
spreads
.
That
does
not
make
it
a
cultural
meme
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Genes
are
copied
.
That
does
not
make
them
memes
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
You
discover
by
yourself
that
fire
is
hot
.
No
person
-
to
-
person
copying
was
necessary
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
yawn
may
trigger
another
yawn
through
an
evolved
response
rather
than
culturally
learned
imitation
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Spread
alone
is
not
enough
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Is
the
meme
the
sentence
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
idea
expressed
by
the
sentence
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
memory
in
somebody
'
s
brain
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
rule
that
allows
the
sentence
to
be
reconstructed
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
pattern
distributed
across
people
''
media
and
artifacts
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Different
memetic
theories
answer
differently
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
style
='
font
-
size
:
1
.
35em
'><
strong
>
Memethical
engineering
is
the
deliberate
design
''
modification
''
and
circulation
of
memes
and
memetic
environments
in
accordance
with
explicit
ethical
goals
.
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
For
example
:
counteracting
propaganda
and
manipulation
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Increasing
epistemic
and
cultural
diversity
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Supporting
critical
reflection
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Increasing
resilience
against
harmful
or
monopolizing
meme
complexes
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Memetic
engineering
asks
:
<
strong
>
How
can
this
spread
?
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Memethical
engineering
must
additionally
ask
:
<
strong
>
Should
it
spread
?
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Who
benefits
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
What
disappears
when
it
succeeds
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Can
people
recognize
the
mechanism
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Can
alternatives
survive
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Success
≠
virality
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
>
Let
us
now
temporarily
leave
theory
behind
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Look
at
ordinary
life
as
a
landscape
of
things
passing
from
person
to
person
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
We
will
move
from
the
smallest
and
fastest
patterns
...
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>...
toward
increasingly
complex
cultural
structures
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Memes
rarely
live
alone
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
They
support
''
trigger
and
protect
one
another
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
fashion
includes
clothes
''
vocabulary
''
gestures
''
music
''
places
and
identities
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
profession
includes
practices
''
jargon
''
values
''
rituals
and
status
symbols
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Religions
''
ideologies
''
artistic
movements
and
institutions
can
contain
enormous
interconnected
systems
of
culturally
transmitted
elements
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Such
complexes
are
often
called
memeplexes
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
>
Think
of
one
meme
you
encountered
<
strong
>
today
strong
>.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Not
necessarily
an
Internet
meme
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Where
did
you
encounter
it
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
What
was
its
external
form
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
What
did
you
reconstruct
internally
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Did
you
reproduce
it
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Did
you
modify
it
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Why
might
this
particular
pattern
survive
?
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
handshake
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
birthday
song
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
stupid
little
drawing
in
a
school
notebook
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
phrase
you
suddenly
notice
yourself
saying
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
floppy
disk
that
survived
its
floppy
disk
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
belief
nobody
remembers
learning
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Culture
replicates
through
us
—
but
never
without
being
reconstructed
by
us
.
strong
>
p
>
Replication
+
Variation
+
Selection
=
Evolution
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
For
most
of
human
history
''
the
diversity
of
life
was
explained
by
one
simple
idea
:
<
strong
>
species
are
fixed
strong
>''
created
once
''
unchanging
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
A
rabbit
begets
a
rabbit
.
An
oak
begets
an
oak
.
World
without
end
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Even
naturalists
who
classified
thousands
of
species
rarely
asked
:
<
em
>
where
did
all
this
variety
come
from
?
em
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
In
1859
''
Charles
Darwin
proposed
something
radical
:
species
are
<
strong
>
not
strong
>
fixed
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
They
change
''
slowly
''
over
generations
—
new
species
arise
from
old
ones
through
an
entirely
natural
''
unplanned
process
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
He
called
it
<
strong
>
natural
selection
strong
>.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
No
designer
.
No
goal
.
Just
a
mechanism
.
p
>
<
p
style
='
font
-
size
:
1
.
6em
'
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Replication
+
Variation
+
Selection
=
Evolution
strong
>
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Darwin
never
used
these
three
words
this
way
—
but
this
is
the
abstract
engine
hiding
inside
his
argument
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Three
ingredients
.
Run
them
together
''
over
and
over
''
and
something
astonishing
happens
:
<
strong
>
design
without
a
designer
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Something
must
be
copied
from
one
generation
to
the
next
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Offspring
resemble
parents
—
not
perfectly
''
but
closely
enough
that
traits
persist
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Darwin
did
not
know
about
DNA
.
He
only
needed
:
<
em
>
like
tends
to
produce
like
em
>.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
No
copy
is
perfect
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Within
any
population
''
individuals
differ
—
in
size
''
colour
''
behaviour
''
shape
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Some
of
this
variation
is
heritable
:
it
gets
passed
on
''
imperfections
and
all
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Without
variation
''
there
is
nothing
for
selection
to
act
upon
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Not
every
variant
survives
.
Not
every
survivor
reproduces
equally
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Resources
are
limited
;
environments
are
demanding
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Whatever
traits
make
an
individual
slightly
better
at
surviving
and
reproducing
become
''
on
average
''
<
strong
>
more
common
strong
>
in
the
next
generation
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Nobody
chooses
.
The
environment
simply
…
filters
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
In
1835
''
Darwin
collected
small
birds
across
the
Galápagos
Islands
—
a
few
hundred
kilometres
off
the
coast
of
Ecuador
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Back
in
London
''
ornithologist
John
Gould
identified
them
:
not
varieties
of
one
species
''
but
<
strong
>
more
than
a
dozen
distinct
species
of
finch
strong
>
—
found
nowhere
else
on
Earth
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Each
island
'
s
finches
had
a
differently
shaped
beak
:
thick
and
crushing
''
thin
and
probing
''
long
and
curved
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
beaks
matched
the
food
available
on
each
island
:
hard
seeds
''
soft
fruit
''
insects
''
nectar
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Darwin
'
s
explanation
:
all
the
finches
descended
from
a
single
ancestral
species
that
reached
the
islands
long
ago
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
On
each
island
:
beak
-
shape
variation
+
a
different
food
source
+
generations
of
selection
→
a
different
finch
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
One
ancestor
.
One
mechanism
.
Many
birds
.
strong
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
finches
are
not
proof
of
evolution
by
themselves
—
but
they
are
an
unusually
clean
illustration
of
the
engine
in
action
''
isolated
on
real
islands
''
at
a
scale
a
visitor
could
actually
observe
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Replication
(
finches
breed
finches
)''
variation
(
beak
shapes
differ
)''
selection
(
local
food
decides
who
thrives
)
—
nothing
more
was
needed
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
So
here
is
a
strange
question
.
<
em
>
Does
this
engine
only
run
on
carbon
?
em
>
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Darwin
described
biological
evolution
.
But
notice
:
nothing
in
the
three
-
step
engine
mentions
DNA
''
cells
''
or
carbon
chemistry
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
It
only
requires
:
entities
that
are
copied
''
imperfectly
''
and
then
differentially
filtered
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Richard
Dawkins
called
this
generalized
claim
<
strong
>
Universal
Darwinism
strong
>:
wherever
you
find
replication
+
variation
+
selection
''
you
will
find
evolution
—
in
biology
or
anywhere
else
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
The
pattern
shows
up
again
and
again
''
once
you
know
to
look
for
it
:
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
your
immune
system
selects
among
antibody
variants
for
the
ones
that
bind
an
intruder
;
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
computer
scientists
breed
populations
of
candidate
solutions
in
“
genetic
algorithms
”;
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
markets
select
among
competing
products
and
firms
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Could
the
same
be
true
of
ideas
themselves
?
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
In
1976
''
Richard
Dawkins
published
<
em
>
The
Selfish
Gene
em
>
—
and
reframed
the
whole
story
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
It
is
not
organisms
that
are
the
true
unit
of
selection
''
he
argued
.
It
is
the
<
strong
>
gene
strong
>.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>“
We
are
survival
machines
—
robot
vehicles
blindly
programmed
to
preserve
the
selfish
molecules
known
as
genes
.”
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Two
roles
''
easy
to
confuse
:
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Replicator
strong
>
—
the
thing
that
gets
copied
.
The
gene
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Vehicle
strong
>
—
the
thing
that
is
built
''
survives
''
and
reproduces
''
carrying
replicators
inside
it
.
The
organism
'
s
body
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Selection
acts
on
vehicles
—
but
its
lasting
effect
is
on
which
replicators
get
copied
into
the
next
generation
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
If
the
gene
is
just
one
possible
kind
of
replicator
…
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>…
could
there
be
others
?
Things
that
are
copied
''
vary
''
and
are
selected
—
but
are
made
of
neither
DNA
nor
protein
?
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Dawkins
proposed
there
could
.
He
needed
just
one
more
word
.
p
>
<
p
style
='
font
-
size
:
1
.
3em
'
class
='
fragment
'>“
I
think
that
a
new
kind
of
replicator
has
recently
emerged
on
this
very
planet
…
I
shall
call
it
a
<
strong
>
meme
strong
>.”
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>—
Richard
Dawkins
''
<
em
>
The
Selfish
Gene
em
>''
1976
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Tunes
''
catch
-
phrases
''
fashions
''
ways
of
making
pots
or
building
arches
—
copied
from
mind
to
mind
''
by
imitation
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Gene
strong
>
—
replicated
via
reproduction
;
vehicle
:
the
body
;
variation
:
mutation
;
selection
:
survival
&
reproduction
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'><
strong
>
Meme
strong
>
—
replicated
via
imitation
;
vehicle
:
brains
''
books
''
screens
;
variation
:
mis
-
copying
''
reinterpretation
;
selection
:
attention
''
memorability
''
usefulness
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
Same
three
-
step
engine
.
A
completely
different
substrate
.
p
>
<
p
class
='
fragment
'>
We
began
with
finches
on
volcanic
islands
and
ended
with
an
idea
that
may
be
living
''
right
now
''
inside
each
of
you
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
If
memes
are
real
replicators
''
then
minds
are
their
islands
—
and
culture
is
the
ongoing
experiment
.
p
><
p
class
='
fragment
'>
In
the
sessions
ahead
''
we
will
look
much
closer
at
how
exactly
this
second
replicator
moves
:
through
imitation
''
through
everyday
life
''
through
law
''
politics
''
and
the
machines
we
now
build
.
p
>
<
div
>
Theory
of
cultural
evolution
. 
div
><
div
><
br
>
div
><
div
>
Excursion
to
Humboldt
Forum
''
maybe
?
div
>
Freud
''
Dawkins
''
Rizzolatti
Visual
memes
–
glyphs
''
emojis
''
latrinalia
&
c
.
Earworms
''
mindworms
''
moving
memes
::
Fashion
''
Style
''
Art
&
c
.
Mediated
memes
''
Urban
memes
Memplexes
''
Religions
''
Ideologies
''
Self
-
reference
Memes
in
Law
''
Politics
&
Propaganda
Memes
&
Cyberspace
Memes
''
Memecoins
''
AIs
Memes
revisited
The
Congress
[Impressum, Datenschutz, Login] Other subprojects of udk.ai linkring: refused.science gardens.digital baumhaus.digital teacher.solar fibel.digital